PrepSolution

BCBA · Study journal

Reinforcement Schedules for the BCBA Exam: Cheat Sheet and Practice

A one-page reference to simple and compound schedules of reinforcement, the response pattern each produces, the matching law and schedule thinning, followed by 11 BCBA practice questions with a reason for every option.

By PrepSolution Editorial TeamPublished Reviewed by PrepSolution Editorial Team17 min read
Inside this articleBCBA
Section preview 01

Where do schedules appear on the BCBA outline?

Domain B, Concepts and Principles, has 24 scored questions and domain G, Behavior-Change Procedures, has 25, out of 175. The BACB does not publish how many questions each task receives, so we cannot tell you how many schedule questions to expect.

Read this section
On this page

Schedule questions on the BCBA exam ask you to do one of three things: name the schedule from a description, predict the pattern of responding it produces, or pick the schedule that fits a clinical goal. All three depend on the same small set of definitions. This page puts those definitions in tables you can review in a few minutes, then gives you 11 practice questions with a reason for every option.

If you are still deciding what to study from, the comparison of BCBA study materials shows what each option covers. The rest of domain B is drilled in the Concepts and Principles practice set.

Definitions and response patterns on this page follow Cooper, Heron and Heward, Applied Behavior Analysis (3rd ed.). Task numbers are from the BACB Test Content Outline (6th ed.). The practice questions are original and are not BACB exam items.

Where do schedules appear on the BCBA outline?

TaskWhat the outline says
B.9Identify and distinguish among simple schedules of reinforcement.
B.10Identify and distinguish among concurrent, multiple, mixed, and chained schedules of reinforcement.
B.23Identify ways the matching law can be used to interpret response allocation.
G.2Design and evaluate differential reinforcement (e.g., DRA, DRO, DRL, DRH) procedures with and without extinction.
G.3Design and evaluate time-based reinforcement (e.g., fixed-time) schedules.
G.16Design and evaluate procedures to maintain desired behavior change following intervention (e.g., schedule thinning, transferring to naturally occurring reinforcers).
Schedule-related tasks in the BACB Test Content Outline (6th ed.). Task wording is the BACB's.

Domain B, Concepts and Principles, has 24 scored questions and domain G, Behavior-Change Procedures, has 25, out of 175. The BACB does not publish how many questions each task receives, so we cannot tell you how many schedule questions to expect.

The four simple schedules

Continuous reinforcement means every occurrence of the behavior is reinforced, and it is written FR 1. It is used to build new behavior. Every other schedule below is intermittent, meaning some occurrences are reinforced and some are not, and intermittent schedules are used to maintain behavior. Extinction is the other end of the range: no occurrence is reinforced.

ScheduleReinforcement is deliveredExampleTypical pattern of responding
Fixed ratio (FR)After a set number of responsesFR 5: a token after every 5th correct math problemHigh rate, with a pause after each reinforcer. Larger ratios produce longer pauses.
Variable ratio (VR)After a number of responses that varies around an averageVR 5: a token after 3, then 7, then 5 correct problemsHigh, steady rate with little or no pause after reinforcement.
Fixed interval (FI)For the first response after a set time has elapsedFI 3-min: the first hand raise after 3 minutes have passed is called onA pause after each reinforcer, then responding that speeds up as the interval ends. On a cumulative record this is the scallop. Overall rate is low to moderate.
Variable interval (VI)For the first response after a time that varies around an averageVI 3-min: the first instance of on-task work after intervals that average 3 minutes is praisedLow to moderate, steady rate with few pauses.
Simple schedules of reinforcement: definition, a teaching example and the response pattern each tends to produce (Cooper, Heron and Heward, 2020).

Three terms attach to these schedules and are tested with them.

  • Post-reinforcement pause. The period of no responding that follows reinforcement on fixed-ratio and fixed-interval schedules.
  • Ratio strain. The breakdown in responding that follows an abrupt increase in a ratio requirement, seen as long or unpredictable pauses, avoidance, emotional behavior or stopping altogether. It is prevented by thinning in small steps.
  • Limited hold. A restriction added to an interval schedule: once the interval has elapsed, reinforcement stays available only for a set time. If no response occurs in that window, the opportunity is lost and the next interval begins.

Interval schedules and time schedules are different

An interval schedule still requires a response. On FI 5-min, nothing is delivered at the 5-minute mark. The reinforcer is delivered for the first response that occurs after 5 minutes have passed. On a fixed-time schedule, written FT 5-min, the reinforcer is delivered every 5 minutes whatever the person is doing. Variable-time (VT) is the same arrangement with times that vary around an average.

Fixed-time and variable-time schedules are response-independent. They are the schedules used in noncontingent reinforcement, and the outline places them in task G.3. When a question says a reinforcer was delivered "regardless of behavior" or "independent of responding," the answer is a time schedule, not an interval schedule.

Compound schedules

A compound schedule combines two or more simple schedules. To name one, answer three questions: how many behaviors are involved, whether the component schedules are available at the same time or one after another, and whether each component has its own stimulus.

ScheduleArrangementStimulus for each component?Example
ConcurrentTwo or more schedules are available at the same time, each for a different response. The person chooses between them.Each option is a separate responseA student can work on math problems (VI 2-min) or reading questions (VI 4-min) during the same period.
MultipleTwo or more schedules for one behavior alternate, one at a time.YesRequests for attention are reinforced on FR 1 while the teacher wears a green lanyard and are not reinforced while the lanyard is red.
MixedThe same as a multiple schedule, with no stimulus to show which component is in effect.NoRequests are sometimes reinforced on FR 1 and sometimes not reinforced, with nothing to signal the change.
ChainedTwo or more schedules must be completed in a set order. Completing one produces the stimulus for the next, and the reinforcer is delivered when the last is completed.YesA learner completes 10 sorting responses (FR 10), a light turns on, and the first response after 1 minute (FI 1-min) produces the reinforcer.
The four compound schedules named in task B.10 (definitions follow Cooper, Heron and Heward, 2020).

A tandem schedule is a chained schedule without the stimuli. It stands to chained as mixed stands to multiple. The outline does not name it in task B.10, and it is worth knowing mainly so you can rule it out as a distractor.

The matching law

The matching law describes how behavior is distributed between options on concurrent schedules. In Herrnstein's 1961 study, the relative rate of responding on each of two alternatives matched the relative rate of reinforcement obtained from each. In practical terms, behavior goes where the reinforcement is, in proportion.

A worked example: two options are available on concurrent VI 30-s VI 60-s schedules. The first can pay off about twice a minute and the second about once a minute, so the first provides about two thirds of the available reinforcement. Matching predicts that about two thirds of responses will go to the first option, not all of them.

The clinical use is interpretation. If a student allocates most of their behavior to calling out and little to hand raising, the matching law suggests looking at how much reinforcement each one produces, how quickly it arrives and how much effort it takes. Shifting behavior means shifting the relative reinforcement.

Schedules used to change rate and to maintain behavior

  • DRH (differential reinforcement of high rates). Reinforcement is delivered when responding is at or above a set rate. Used to increase a behavior that occurs too seldom.
  • DRL (differential reinforcement of low rates). Reinforcement is delivered when responding is at or below a set rate, or when responses are spaced by a minimum time. Used to reduce, not eliminate, a behavior that is acceptable in moderation.
  • Schedule thinning. Gradually increasing the response or time requirement, for example FR 1 to FR 2 to FR 4, so that behavior is maintained with less frequent reinforcement. Thinning too fast produces ratio strain.

Practice questions

Question 1: Naming a ratio schedule (task B.9)

A learner in a vocational program receives a token after every eighth item packed correctly. Which schedule is in effect?

  • A. FR 8
  • B. VR 8
  • C. FI 8-min
  • D. FT 8-min

Best answer: A. The requirement is a number of responses, so it is a ratio schedule, and the number is the same every time, so it is fixed. A token after every eighth response is FR 8.

  • B is not the best answer. VR 8 would deliver the token after a number of correct items that changes from one reinforcer to the next and averages eight.
  • C is not the best answer. FI 8-min would reinforce the first response after 8 minutes had elapsed. The scene counts items, not time.
  • D is not the best answer. FT 8-min would deliver a token every 8 minutes whatever the learner was doing. Here the token depends on packing.

Question 2: Naming an interval schedule (task B.9)

A teacher sets a vibrating timer to go off after intervals of varying length that average 4 minutes. After each vibration, the teacher praises a target student for the first instance of on-task work observed. Which schedule describes the praise?

  • A. VR 4
  • B. FI 4-min
  • C. VT 4-min
  • D. VI 4-min

Best answer: D. Praise is delivered for the first response after a period of time, so it is an interval schedule. The time changes around an average of 4 minutes, so it is variable: VI 4-min.

  • A is not the best answer. VR 4 counts responses. Praise would follow an average of four instances of on-task work, with no reference to time.
  • B is not the best answer. FI 4-min would use the same 4-minute interval every time. The timer intervals vary.
  • C is not the best answer. VT 4-min would deliver praise when the timer went off whether or not the student was on task. Here the teacher waits for on-task work.

Question 3: Interval or time (tasks B.9 and G.3)

In a day program, staff give a client access to a preferred music player for one minute every 5 minutes. They do this whatever the client is doing at that moment. Which schedule is this?

  • A. FI 5-min
  • B. FT 5-min
  • C. FR 5
  • D. VI 5-min

Best answer: B. The reinforcer is delivered on the basis of time alone, and no response is required. That is a time schedule, and because the time is the same on each occasion it is fixed-time: FT 5-min.

  • A is not the best answer. FI 5-min requires a response. The reinforcer would be delivered for the first target response after 5 minutes had passed, not at the 5-minute mark regardless of behavior.
  • C is not the best answer. FR 5 would deliver the reinforcer after every fifth response. No response count is involved.
  • D is not the best answer. VI 5-min requires a response and uses intervals that vary around 5 minutes. The schedule here is response-independent and the time is constant.

Question 4: Reading a pattern (task B.9)

A cumulative record shows the same pattern after every reinforcer: a period with no responding, then slow responding that speeds up steadily until the next reinforcer is delivered. Which simple schedule most likely produced this record?

  • A. Fixed ratio
  • B. Variable ratio
  • C. Fixed interval
  • D. Variable interval

Best answer: C. A pause after reinforcement followed by a gradually accelerating rate toward the end of the interval is the fixed-interval scallop. Responding early in the interval has never been reinforced, and responding near its end has.

  • A is not the best answer. Fixed ratio also produces a pause after reinforcement, but the pause is followed by a quick shift to a high, steady rate until the ratio is completed. The record shows gradual acceleration.
  • B is not the best answer. Variable ratio produces a high, steady rate with little or no pause after reinforcement.
  • D is not the best answer. Variable interval produces a steady, low to moderate rate. Because the next interval cannot be predicted, there is no consistent pause and no acceleration.

Question 5: Choosing a schedule for a goal (task B.9)

A behavior analyst wants a learner to respond at a high, consistent rate during fluency practice, with as little pausing after reinforcement as possible. The behavior is already established. Which simple schedule is most likely to produce this?

  • A. Fixed interval
  • B. Variable ratio
  • C. Fixed ratio
  • D. Variable interval

Best answer: B. Variable-ratio schedules tend to produce high, steady rates of responding with little or no post-reinforcement pause, because reinforcement depends on the number of responses and the next reinforcer cannot be predicted.

  • A is not the best answer. Fixed interval produces pauses after reinforcement and a low to moderate overall rate. Responding faster does not bring the reinforcer sooner.
  • C is not the best answer. Fixed ratio produces a high rate, but with a pause after each reinforcer, and the pause grows as the ratio grows.
  • D is not the best answer. Variable interval produces steady responding, but at a low to moderate rate, because rate has little effect on how often reinforcement is delivered.

Question 6: When thinning goes wrong (tasks B.9 and G.16)

A learner has been completing worksheets reliably on FR 5. The team moves directly to FR 40. The learner now takes long, unpredictable breaks, complains, and on some days stops working. What is this effect called?

  • A. Ratio strain
  • B. Extinction burst
  • C. Behavioral contrast
  • D. Spontaneous recovery

Best answer: A. Ratio strain is the disruption in responding that follows an abrupt increase in a ratio requirement. Long pauses, avoidance, emotional behavior and stopping are its usual signs. The remedy is to return to a ratio that maintained responding and thin in smaller steps.

  • B is not the best answer. An extinction burst is a temporary increase in a behavior when its reinforcer is withheld completely. Reinforcement is still available here, and responding has fallen.
  • C is not the best answer. Behavioral contrast is a change in responding in one component of a multiple schedule in the direction opposite to a change made in the other component. Only one schedule is described.
  • D is not the best answer. Spontaneous recovery is the brief return of a behavior that had been reduced by extinction. No extinction procedure is in place.

Question 7: Limited hold (task B.9)

A schedule is written VI 2-min with a limited hold of 10 seconds. What does the limited hold add?

  • A. Reinforcement is delivered 10 seconds after the response
  • B. The learner must respond for 10 seconds continuously to earn reinforcement
  • C. Each interval may vary by no more than 10 seconds from the average
  • D. Once an interval has elapsed, reinforcement is available only for the next 10 seconds

Best answer: D. A limited hold restricts how long reinforcement stays available after the interval ends. If the learner responds within 10 seconds, the response is reinforced. If not, that opportunity is lost and the next interval begins. It is used to encourage prompt responding on interval schedules.

  • A is not the best answer. A delay between the response and the reinforcer is a delay to reinforcement. It is not part of the definition of a limited hold.
  • B is not the best answer. A requirement to respond for a period of time describes a duration requirement, not a limited hold.
  • C is not the best answer. How far intervals vary around the average is a property of the variable schedule itself. The limited hold concerns what happens after an interval has elapsed.

Question 8: Multiple or mixed (task B.10)

A child's requests for adult attention are reinforced every time while the adult wears a green wristband and are never reinforced while the adult wears a red wristband. The two conditions alternate through the day. Which compound schedule is this?

  • A. Concurrent schedule
  • B. Multiple schedule
  • C. Mixed schedule
  • D. Chained schedule

Best answer: B. One behavior is exposed to two schedules, reinforcement and extinction, that alternate, and each has its own stimulus. Alternating components with a stimulus correlated with each one is a multiple schedule.

  • A is not the best answer. A concurrent schedule makes two or more schedules available at the same time for different responses. Here one schedule is in effect at a time, for one response.
  • C is not the best answer. A mixed schedule alternates components in the same way but has no stimulus to show which one is in effect. The wristbands are those stimuli.
  • D is not the best answer. A chained schedule requires the components to be completed in a fixed order to reach one reinforcer. Here the components alternate and each operates independently.

Question 9: Matching law (tasks B.10 and B.23)

During independent work, a student can earn teacher praise for two tasks that are available at the same time. Work on task 1 is praised on a VI 1-min schedule and work on task 2 on a VI 3-min schedule. If the student's behavior follows the matching law, about what share of responses will go to task 1?

  • A. About one quarter
  • B. About one half
  • C. About three quarters
  • D. All of them

Best answer: C. Task 1 can produce about 3 reinforcers in 3 minutes and task 2 about 1, so task 1 provides about three quarters of the reinforcement. The matching law predicts that the share of responses given to an option will match the share of reinforcement obtained from it, so about three quarters of responses go to task 1.

  • A is not the best answer. One quarter is the share predicted for task 2, the option with the leaner schedule.
  • B is not the best answer. One half would be expected if the two options produced reinforcement at the same rate.
  • D is not the best answer. Matching predicts proportional allocation. On concurrent interval schedules some responding to the leaner option continues, because reinforcement keeps becoming available there with the passage of time.

Question 10: Chained or tandem (task B.10)

A learner must press a button 10 times while a blue light is on. The tenth press turns the blue light off and a green light on. The first press after 1 minute with the green light on produces a snack. Which schedule is this?

  • A. Multiple FR 10 FI 1-min
  • B. Tandem FR 10 FI 1-min
  • C. Concurrent FR 10 FI 1-min
  • D. Chained FR 10 FI 1-min

Best answer: D. Two schedules must be completed in a fixed order, each has its own stimulus, completing the first produces the stimulus for the second, and the reinforcer is delivered only when the second is completed. That is a chained schedule.

  • A is not the best answer. In a multiple schedule the components alternate and each one delivers its own reinforcement. Here the first component produces only the next stimulus.
  • B is not the best answer. A tandem schedule has the same sequence requirement with no stimulus change between components. The lights are the stimuli that make this chained.
  • C is not the best answer. A concurrent schedule offers two schedules at the same time for different responses. Here the schedules occur one after the other for the same response.

Question 11: Differential reinforcement of rate (task G.2)

A student asks the teacher for help about 20 times in each class, often before trying the problem. The teacher wants the student to keep asking for help when it is needed, but less often. The student earns free time if they ask for help five or fewer times in a class. Which procedure is this?

  • A. DRL
  • B. DRH
  • C. DRO
  • D. DRA

Best answer: A. Reinforcement is delivered when the behavior occurs at or below a set number in the session. That is differential reinforcement of low rates, in its full-session form. It fits because the goal is to reduce the behavior and keep it, not remove it.

  • B is not the best answer. DRH reinforces responding at or above a set rate and is used to increase a behavior.
  • C is not the best answer. DRO delivers reinforcement when the target behavior does not occur at all during a period. The student is allowed up to five requests.
  • D is not the best answer. DRA reinforces a specific alternative behavior in place of the target behavior. No alternative response is named in the contingency. The criterion is the count of the target behavior itself.

How should you study schedules?

  • Learn the two questions that name any simple schedule: is the requirement responses or time, and is it the same each time or variable?
  • Learn the patterns as a set of four, and practice recognizing them from a description of a cumulative record.
  • For compound schedules, sort by three features: one behavior or more, same time or in sequence, with or without a stimulus for each component.
  • Whenever a question mentions time, check for a response requirement before you choose between FI and FT.

When schedules feel secure, move on to how they are used in procedures. The assessment and intervention cases apply differential reinforcement to function-based plans, and the BCBA study guide shows where domains B and G fit in a study sequence.

PrepSolution Editorial Team

Exam-prep editorial team

About PrepSolution

References

  1. [1] Behavior Analyst Certification Board (2022). BCBA Test Content Outline (6th ed.). BACB. BACB
  2. [2] Cooper, J. O., Heron, T. E., & Heward, W. L. (2020). Applied Behavior Analysis (3rd ed.). Pearson.
  3. [3] Ferster, C. B., & Skinner, B. F. (1957). Schedules of Reinforcement. Appleton-Century-Crofts.
  4. [4] Herrnstein, R. J. (1961). Relative and absolute strength of response as a function of frequency of reinforcement. Journal of the Experimental Analysis of Behavior, 4(3), 267-272. Journal of the Experimental Analysis of Behavior, 4(3), 267-272

Help us improve this guide

How helpful was this article?

One tap helps us understand what’s useful.

Not helpful → Very helpful

Frequently asked questions

Fixed ratio, variable ratio, fixed interval and variable interval. Ratio schedules reinforce after a number of responses. Interval schedules reinforce the first response after a period of time. Fixed means the requirement is constant, and variable means it changes around an average.

Variable ratio. It tends to produce a high, steady rate with little or no pause after reinforcement, because reinforcement depends on the number of responses and the next reinforcer cannot be predicted.

A fixed-interval schedule reinforces the first response after a set time has passed, so a response is required. A fixed-time schedule delivers the reinforcer after a set time whatever the person is doing. Fixed-time schedules are used in noncontingent reinforcement.

Both alternate two or more schedules for one behavior. In a multiple schedule each component has its own stimulus, so the learner can tell which schedule is in effect. In a mixed schedule there is no such stimulus.

On concurrent schedules, the proportion of responses given to an option tends to match the proportion of reinforcement obtained from that option. Herrnstein described the relation in 1961.

Ratio strain is the breakdown in responding that follows an abrupt increase in a ratio requirement. It shows as long pauses, avoidance or stopping, and it is prevented by thinning the schedule in small steps.

Choose your BCBA study materials

Compare BCBA prep options by what they cover, how questions are explained and what they cost, then build your plan around the 6th edition outline.

Related Articles