PrepSolution

Human Resources · Study journal

PHR Employee and Labor Relations: 10 Worked Practice Questions

Ten original PHR questions on Section 7, supervisors, campaign speech, Weingarten rights, good-faith bargaining, election bars and OSHA retaliation, each answer checked against the statute.

By Sarah L.Published Reviewed by PrepSolution Editorial Team12 min read
Inside this articleHuman Resources
Section preview 01

What does Employee and Labor Relations cover on the PHR?

HRCI's PHR Exam Content Outline, which took effect in 2024, describes the area as managing, monitoring and promoting "legally compliant programs and policies that impact the employee experience." It lists five responsibilities:

Read this section
On this page

PHR questions on employee and labor relations ask you to apply the National Labor Relations Act, OSHA retaliation rules and basic complaint handling to a workplace scenario. The ten questions below are written that way: a short situation, four plausible responses, and the reason each wrong answer fails. Every legal point is checked against the statute or the Supreme Court decision it comes from.

Employee and Labor Relations carries 20% of the PHR, more than any other functional area, so it is worth a focused session. The PHR exam prep course covers it with a full question bank and timed mock exams, and the PHR study guide shows where it sits among the seven areas.

What does Employee and Labor Relations cover on the PHR?

HRCI's PHR Exam Content Outline, which took effect in 2024, describes the area as managing, monitoring and promoting "legally compliant programs and policies that impact the employee experience." It lists five responsibilities:

ResponsibilityWhat it coversExamples HRCI gives
6.1Programs and US federal laws that promote inclusionEmployee resource groups, community outreach, corporate social responsibility
6.2Workplace programs under US federal health, safety, security and privacy lawsOSHA, workers' compensation, emergency response, workplace violence, substance abuse, legal postings, investigations
6.3Interpreting and enforcing organizational policiesEmployee handbook, SOPs, time and attendance, expenses
6.4Resolving employee complaints, concerns and conflictsInvestigate, document, recommend solutions, grievance and ADR procedures
6.5Positive employee and labor relations under US federal laws for union and nonunion workplacesAntidiscrimination policies, harassment
PHR Functional Area 06, Employee and Labor Relations (20%). Responsibility wording summarized from HRCI's PHR Exam Content Outline.

The NLRA questions below fall under 6.5, the OSHA question under 6.2, and the grievance and investigation questions under 6.4. The NLRA Section 7 notes and unfair labor practice notes cover the law in summary form if you want a refresher first.

Practice questions

These are original PrepSolution practice questions, written from the NLRA (29 U.S.C. 152, 157 to 159), the OSH Act (29 U.S.C. 660(c)) and NLRB v. J. Weingarten, Inc., 420 U.S. 251 (1975). They are not HRCI exam items. They stick to the statute and settled Supreme Court law, not to Board decisions that change with the Board's membership.

Question 1

At a nonunion distribution center, three warehouse employees sign a joint letter to management saying their pay is below other warehouses in the area and asking for a raise. The operations manager wants to terminate the employee who drafted the letter for "stirring things up." What should HR advise?

  • A. The termination is lawful, because the employees have no union and the NLRA protects only union activity
  • B. The termination is lawful, because complaints about pay are a management prerogative
  • C. Do not terminate, because joint action about pay is concerted activity for mutual aid or protection under Section 7, and firing for it interferes with that right
  • D. Do not terminate, but issue a written warning for going outside the chain of command

Best answer: C. Section 7 protects employees' right "to engage in other concerted activities for the purpose of collective bargaining or other mutual aid or protection." It is not limited to union members. Section 8(a)(1) makes it an unfair labor practice to "interfere with, restrain, or coerce employees in the exercise of" Section 7 rights.

  • A is wrong because Section 7 rights belong to employees, union or not.
  • B is wrong because setting pay is the employer's decision, but disciplining employees for jointly raising it is not protected by that prerogative.
  • D is wrong because disciplining the employees for the concerted complaint itself would still interfere with their Section 7 rights.

Question 2

A union is organizing a hotel. Which of these workers is excluded from the NLRA's definition of "employee," and so cannot be part of the bargaining unit?

  • A. A front-desk shift lead who has authority to hire, discipline and assign housekeepers using independent judgment
  • B. A part-time housekeeper who works 20 hours a week
  • C. A banquet server hired three weeks ago
  • D. A maintenance technician on probation

Best answer: A. Section 2(3) excludes "any individual employed as a supervisor." Section 2(11) defines a supervisor as someone with authority, in the employer's interest, to hire, discipline, assign and similar actions, where the authority "requires the use of independent judgment."

  • B is wrong because part-time status does not remove someone from the definition of employee.
  • C is wrong because length of service does not affect NLRA coverage.
  • D is wrong because probationary status is not one of the statutory exclusions.

Question 3

During an organizing campaign, a plant manager plans to speak to employees. Which statement is protected by Section 8(c) of the NLRA?

  • A. "If the union wins, we will have to close this plant and move the work to our other site."
  • B. "We believe our employees are better off dealing with us directly, and here is why we think so."
  • C. "Vote no and everyone gets a 5% raise in January."
  • D. "Anyone who signs a union card will not be considered for the supervisor opening."

Best answer: B. Section 8(c) says the expression of "any views, argument, or opinion" is not an unfair labor practice "if such expression contains no threat of reprisal or force or promise of benefit." An opinion with reasons, and no threat or promise, fits.

  • A is wrong because it threatens a reprisal (closure) tied to the vote.
  • C is wrong because it promises a benefit for voting against the union.
  • D is wrong because it threatens discrimination in a term of employment to discourage union membership, which Section 8(a)(3) prohibits.

Question 4

In a unionized warehouse, a supervisor calls an employee into a meeting to ask about missing inventory. The employee says, "I think this could get me fired. I want my steward here." What are the employer's lawful options?

  • A. Continue the interview, because the employee has no right to representation in an investigation
  • B. Allow the steward to attend, or tell the employee it will not continue the interview without the employee proceeding alone and then decide on the information it already has
  • C. Postpone the interview and begin bargaining with the steward over the discipline
  • D. Deny the request and discipline the employee for refusing to cooperate

Best answer: B. In NLRB v. J. Weingarten, Inc., the Supreme Court upheld the Board's rule that denying an employee's request for a union representative at an investigatory interview the employee "reasonably believed might result in disciplinary action" violates Section 8(a)(1). The Court also said the employer "is free to carry on his inquiry without interviewing the employee," leaving the employee to choose between an interview without the representative or no interview.

  • A is wrong because the employee requested representation and reasonably fears discipline, which is when the right applies.
  • C is wrong because the Court said the employer "has no duty to bargain with any union representative who may be permitted to attend the investigatory interview."
  • D is wrong because compelling the interview after a valid request, and penalizing the refusal, interferes with the right the Court recognized.

Question 5

Contract talks have gone on for months. The union says the employer is bargaining in bad faith because it has refused the union's wage proposal and made no counteroffer on pension contributions. The employer has met regularly and discussed each proposal. Under Section 8(d), which statement is accurate?

  • A. The employer must agree to at least one union proposal to show good faith
  • B. Refusing any proposal is an unfair labor practice
  • C. The employer must accept binding arbitration of the wage dispute
  • D. The duty to bargain requires meeting and conferring in good faith, but does not compel agreement or a concession

Best answer: D. Section 8(d) defines bargaining as the mutual obligation "to meet at reasonable times and confer in good faith with respect to wages, hours, and other terms and conditions of employment," and adds that the obligation "does not compel either party to agree to a proposal or require the making of a concession."

  • A is wrong because the statute expressly does not compel agreement.
  • B is wrong for the same reason. Whether conduct as a whole shows bad faith depends on more than one refusal.
  • C is wrong because nothing in Section 8(d) requires binding arbitration of contract terms.

Question 6

Employees at a call center voted against union representation in a valid NLRB election in March. In September, a different union files a petition for an election in the same unit. What happens?

  • A. The Board can hold a new election because a different union filed
  • B. No election can be directed in that unit until twelve months have passed since the valid election
  • C. An election can be held because six months have passed since the last one
  • D. A new election can be held if 30% of employees sign cards

Best answer: B. Section 9(c)(3): "No election shall be directed in any bargaining unit or any subdivision within which in the preceding twelve-month period, a valid election shall have been held."

  • A is wrong because the bar applies to the unit, whichever union petitions.
  • C is wrong because the statutory bar is twelve months, not six.
  • D is wrong because the twelve-month bar applies regardless of card support.

Question 7

An employee testified at an NLRB hearing about a coworker's discharge. Two weeks later her manager moves her to a less desirable shift and says it is "because of the hearing." Which provision is most directly violated?

  • A. Section 8(a)(4), which prohibits discrimination against an employee for giving testimony under the Act
  • B. Section 8(a)(5), refusal to bargain
  • C. Section 8(b)(1)(A), union restraint of employees
  • D. Section 9(a), exclusive representation

Best answer: A. Section 8(a)(4) makes it an unfair labor practice "to discharge or otherwise discriminate against an employee because he has filed charges or given testimony under" the Act. A shift change because of her testimony is discrimination in a term of employment.

  • B is wrong because refusal to bargain concerns the employer's duty to the union, not retaliation against one employee.
  • C is wrong because it describes unfair labor practices by a labor organization.
  • D is wrong because Section 9(a) sets out exclusive representation, not a prohibition on retaliation.

Question 8

In a unionized plant, an employee wants to raise a scheduling grievance with her manager herself, without the union. What does Section 9(a) allow?

  • A. Nothing; all grievances must go through the union
  • B. The employee may present the grievance and have it adjusted directly, as long as the adjustment is consistent with the contract and the union has an opportunity to be present
  • C. The employee may settle the grievance on any terms she and the manager agree, even if they differ from the contract
  • D. Only stewards may present grievances

Best answer: B. Section 9(a) gives individual employees "the right at any time to present grievances to their employer and to have such grievances adjusted, without the intervention of the bargaining representative, as long as the adjustment is not inconsistent with the terms of a collective-bargaining contract," provided "the bargaining representative has been given opportunity to be present at such adjustment."

  • A is wrong because the proviso preserves the individual right to present grievances.
  • C is wrong because the adjustment cannot be inconsistent with the contract.
  • D is wrong because the statute gives the right to "any individual employee or a group of employees."

Question 9

A union organizer tells an employee who refuses to sign an authorization card that "people who don't support us won't be safe in the parking lot." Who has committed an unfair labor practice?

  • A. The employer, for allowing the organizer on site
  • B. No one, because unions are not covered by the NLRA's unfair labor practice sections
  • C. The employee, for refusing to sign
  • D. The union, under Section 8(b)(1)(A), for restraining or coercing an employee in the exercise of Section 7 rights

Best answer: D. Section 8(b)(1)(A) makes it an unfair labor practice for a labor organization or its agents "to restrain or coerce employees in the exercise of the rights guaranteed in section 157." Section 7 includes the right "to refrain from any or all of such activities."

  • A is wrong because the coercion came from the union's agent, and nothing in the scenario shows the employer did anything.
  • B is wrong because Section 8(b) lists unfair labor practices by unions.
  • C is wrong because refraining from union activity is itself a Section 7 right.

Question 10

An employee reports a blocked fire exit to OSHA. A week later she is moved off overtime and told it is because she "went outside the company." By what deadline must she file a retaliation complaint under section 11(c) of the OSH Act?

  • A. 180 days after the violation
  • B. 300 days after the violation
  • C. 30 days after the violation
  • D. There is no deadline for safety retaliation

Best answer: C. 29 U.S.C. 660(c)(2): an employee who believes she was discharged or discriminated against in violation of this subsection "may, within thirty days after such violation occurs, file a complaint with the Secretary."

  • A is wrong because 180 days is the general deadline for an EEOC charge, not for OSH Act section 11(c).
  • B is wrong because 300 days is the extended EEOC charge deadline where a state or local agency enforces a similar law.
  • D is wrong because the statute sets a thirty-day deadline.

What patterns do these questions share?

  • The employer's right to manage does not cover penalizing protected activity. Employers set pay and run investigations, but disciplining employees for joint complaints, testimony or a representation request crosses the line.
  • Read for threats and promises. Most campaign-speech items turn on whether a statement threatens a reprisal or promises a benefit.
  • Know who is excluded. Supervisors and independent contractors are outside the NLRA, so they are outside any bargaining unit.
  • Good faith is a process standard. The duty to bargain is about meeting and conferring, not about outcomes.
  • Deadlines differ by statute. OSH Act retaliation complaints have a thirty-day window, much shorter than EEOC charges.

For question 10, the EEOC charge deadlines in the distractors come from Title VII, 42 U.S.C. 2000e-5(e)(1). Knowing which deadline belongs to which statute is a common PHR discriminator.

Where to go from here

If you missed the union campaign items, the union organizing and election notes and the collective bargaining notes cover the process from cards to contract. For discipline and investigations, see the progressive discipline notes. If you have sat the exam already and are planning a second attempt, the PHR retake plan shows how to use your results report to target this area, and the PHR exam prep course has the full question bank.

Sarah L.

PrepSolution Content Editor, HR

About PrepSolution

References

  1. [1] HRCI (2024). PHR Exam Content Outline. HR Certification Institute. HR Certification Institute
  2. [2] U.S. Congress (2024). 29 U.S.C. 152, NLRA definitions. United States Code, govinfo.gov. United States Code, govinfo.gov
  3. [3] U.S. Congress (2024). 29 U.S.C. 157, rights of employees (NLRA Section 7). United States Code, govinfo.gov. United States Code, govinfo.gov
  4. [4] U.S. Congress (2024). 29 U.S.C. 158, unfair labor practices (NLRA Section 8). United States Code, govinfo.gov. United States Code, govinfo.gov
  5. [5] U.S. Congress (2024). 29 U.S.C. 159, representatives and elections (NLRA Section 9). United States Code, govinfo.gov. United States Code, govinfo.gov
  6. [6] Supreme Court of the United States (1975). NLRB v. J. Weingarten, Inc., 420 U.S. 251. Library of Congress, U.S. Reports. Library of Congress, U.S. Reports
  7. [7] U.S. Congress (2024). 29 U.S.C. 660, OSH Act section 11(c). United States Code, govinfo.gov. United States Code, govinfo.gov
  8. [8] U.S. Congress (2024). 42 U.S.C. 2000e-5, Title VII enforcement provisions. United States Code, govinfo.gov. United States Code, govinfo.gov

Help us improve this guide

How helpful was this article?

One tap helps us understand what’s useful.

Not helpful → Very helpful

Frequently asked questions

Twenty percent, the largest of the seven functional areas in HRCI's PHR Exam Content Outline that took effect in 2024.

Yes. Section 7 protects employees' right to engage in concerted activities for mutual aid or protection, whether or not a union is involved, and Section 8(a)(1) bars employers from interfering with that right.

Under NLRB v. J. Weingarten, Inc. (1975), a union-represented employee who reasonably believes an investigatory interview may lead to discipline can request a union representative. The right arises only on request, and the employer may choose not to continue the interview.

Section 8(c) protects the expression of views, argument or opinion, as long as it contains no threat of reprisal or force or promise of benefit.

No. Section 8(d) says the duty to bargain does not compel either party to agree to a proposal or require the making of a concession.

Section 9(c)(3) bars a Board-directed election in a unit within twelve months after a valid election in that unit.

Thirty days after the violation, under section 11(c)(2) of the OSH Act, 29 U.S.C. 660(c)(2).

Keep practicing for the PHR.

Review the study tools, access options and price, or start with free practice.

Related Articles