PrepSolution

SAT · Study journal

SAT Command of Evidence Practice Questions: Textual and Quantitative

Ten original Digital SAT Command of Evidence questions, five textual and five with data tables, with each answer checked and the traps explained.

By PrepSolution Editorial TeamPublished Reviewed by PrepSolution SAT Editorial Team13 min read
Inside this articleSAT
Section preview 01

What are SAT Command of Evidence questions?

College Board's Assessment Framework defines Command of Evidence as questions where students "use textual evidence (e.g., a fact, detail, or example) or quantitative evidence (i.e., data from an informational graphic) to appropriately support, challenge, or otherwise respond to a specified claim or point." It sits in the Information and Ideas domain with Central Ideas and Details and Inferences.

Read this section
On this page

Command of Evidence questions punish a habit that serves students well elsewhere: picking a true statement. On these items, two or three options are often accurate, and only one does the job the question names. The skill being tested is matching evidence to a claim, which is also what admissions essays and college papers ask for.

This article drills both forms with 10 questions written for this page. For full-length adaptive practice and score tracking, see the SAT prep course. For the other 10 Reading and Writing question types, read every SAT Reading and Writing question type explained.

What are SAT Command of Evidence questions?

College Board's Assessment Framework defines Command of Evidence as questions where students "use textual evidence (e.g., a fact, detail, or example) or quantitative evidence (i.e., data from an informational graphic) to appropriately support, challenge, or otherwise respond to a specified claim or point." It sits in the Information and Ideas domain with Central Ideas and Details and Inferences.

FeatureDetail
Section length54 questions in 64 minutes, in two 32-minute modules
DomainInformation and Ideas, about 26% of scored questions (12 to 14)
Skills in the domainCentral Ideas and Details; Command of Evidence (Textual, Quantitative); Inferences
Graphics usedTables, bar graphs and line graphs
Text length25 to 150 words, one question per text
Where Command of Evidence sits in the Reading and Writing section. Source: College Board Assessment Framework, Table 10, and the SAT structure and Reading and Writing pages.

College Board does not publish a separate count for Command of Evidence, so the 12 to 14 figure covers the whole Information and Ideas domain.

How do you answer Command of Evidence questions?

  • Find the claim and say what would prove it. "Drip irrigation produced the highest yield in both years" needs a comparison across all methods in each year.
  • Check the direction. Support, weaken, illustrate and complete are different jobs. A question that asks what would weaken a claim wants evidence against it.
  • For data items, read the labels first. Check units, groups and years before reading any numbers.
  • Eliminate true-but-irrelevant options. If an option is accurate but does not address the claim's comparison, it is wrong.
  • Eliminate misread data. Some options swap groups or years, or state a trend the table does not show. Check each number against the table.

These are original PrepSolution practice questions. All texts, quotations, studies and data are invented for practice; none are College Board material, and the people named are fictional.

Practice questions: textual evidence

Question 1: Support a hypothesis

Text. City squirrels often bury food near streetlights. Biologist Rosa Mendel hypothesizes that they do so because the light helps them relocate their caches after dark.

Which finding, if true, would most directly support Mendel's hypothesis?

  • A. City squirrels bury more food each year than squirrels living in forests.
  • B. Squirrels are generally more active during daylight than at night.
  • C. Squirrels recovered a greater share of caches buried near working streetlights than of caches buried near streetlights that had been switched off.
  • D. Most of the streetlights in Mendel's study stood beside park paths.

Best answer: C. The hypothesis links light to finding caches after dark. This finding compares lit and unlit spots and shows better recovery where the light works, which is the link the hypothesis proposes.

  • A is weaker. This compares city and forest squirrels and says nothing about light or recovering caches.
  • B is weaker. If anything, this cuts against the idea that night-time relocation matters.
  • D is weaker. Where the lights stood does not show whether light helps squirrels find their food.

Question 2: Weaken a claim

Text. Historian Paul Okafor argues that the opening of the Riverton Canal in 1851 increased trade in the town, mainly because merchants could ship goods more cheaply by water than overland.

Which finding, if true, would most directly weaken Okafor's argument?

  • A. Riverton's trade grew by about the same amount in the decade before the canal opened as in the decade after.
  • B. Several merchants built new warehouses beside the canal after it opened.
  • C. The canal took six years to build.
  • D. Canal shipping rates were lower than overland rates for most goods.

Best answer: A. If trade was already growing at the same pace before the canal, the canal does not explain the growth. That undercuts the causal claim directly.

  • B is weaker. New warehouses by the canal suggest the canal mattered, which supports the argument.
  • C is weaker. Construction time has no bearing on whether the canal increased trade.
  • D is weaker. Lower canal rates support the mechanism Okafor proposes.

Question 3: Illustrate a claim with a quotation

Text. In the poem "Kitchen Window" by the fictional poet Lena Hart, the speaker finds comfort in the small routines of her household.

Which quotation from "Kitchen Window" most effectively illustrates the claim?

  • A. "The station clock runs fast, the trains run late, / and no one I pass looks up to meet my eyes."
  • B. "I packed the boxes, sealed them, wrote new names / on every door of a house that was not mine."
  • C. "The garden I once kept has gone to seed; / the gate swings open now on rusted hinge."
  • D. "The kettle's morning whistle, never late, / is how I know that I am home again."

Best answer: D. The claim needs a routine and comfort. The kettle's whistle happens every morning ("never late") and tells the speaker she is home, which is comfort drawn from routine.

  • A is weaker. This describes an unfriendly public place, not a household routine.
  • B is weaker. Moving into an unfamiliar house suggests disruption, not comfort.
  • C is weaker. A neglected garden suggests loss or decline, not a comforting routine.

Question 4: Support a cause

Text. A student claims that a new protected bike lane on Elm Street reduced the number of cars using that street.

Which finding, if true, would most directly support the student's claim?

  • A. The number of cyclists on Elm Street doubled after the lane opened.
  • B. Car counts on Elm Street fell after the lane opened, while counts on nearby streets without bike lanes stayed about the same.
  • C. Most residents surveyed said they liked the new bike lane.
  • D. Car counts fell by about the same amount on every street in the city during the same period.

Best answer: B. The claim is about cars and needs the lane as the cause. Comparing Elm Street with similar streets without lanes rules out a citywide drop, so the lane is the likely cause.

  • A is weaker. More cyclists does not show fewer cars.
  • C is weaker. Opinions about the lane do not measure traffic.
  • D is weaker. A citywide drop of the same size points to a cause other than the lane, which weakens the claim.

Question 5: Challenge an explanation

Text. Botanists have observed a flowering shrub spreading north over the past 30 years. A team led by Ines Varga attributes the spread to warmer winters, which allow more seedlings to survive.

Which finding, if true, would most directly challenge the team's explanation?

  • A. The shrub has spread north at the same rate in regions where winter temperatures have not changed.
  • B. Seedlings of the shrub rarely survive winters with long periods below freezing.
  • C. Winters in the shrub's northern range have grown warmer over the past 30 years.
  • D. The shrub produces more seeds in warm years than in cool ones.

Best answer: A. If the shrub spreads just as fast where winters stayed the same, warmer winters cannot explain the spread. That is direct evidence against the proposed cause.

  • B is weaker. This fits the explanation: cold kills seedlings, so warming would help them survive.
  • C is weaker. This confirms the warming the explanation depends on.
  • D is weaker. More seeds in warm years is consistent with warming helping the shrub.

Practice questions: quantitative evidence

Question 6: Trend and comparison

Text. A librarian claims that interest in the library's new coding workshop grew over its first four months, while interest in the long-running book club held steady. ______

MonthCoding workshopBook club
January1220
February1821
March2519
April3120
Monthly attendance at two library programs (invented data).

Which choice most effectively uses data from the table to complete the statement?

  • A. The book club had more attendees than the coding workshop in January and February.
  • B. Coding workshop attendance reached 31 in April, the highest monthly figure for either program.
  • C. Coding workshop attendance rose from 12 in January to 31 in April, while book club attendance stayed between 19 and 21.
  • D. Both programs had their highest attendance in April.

Best answer: C. The claim has two parts: growth for the workshop and stability for the book club. Only this option addresses both, with figures that match the table.

  • A is weaker. This is accurate but compares the programs in two months. It does not show growth or stability.
  • B is weaker. This is accurate but gives one month for one program. It shows neither growth over time nor the book club's pattern.
  • D is weaker. This misreads the table. The book club peaked at 21 in February, not April.

Question 7: Highest in every year

Text. Agronomists compared three irrigation methods on test fields over two growing seasons. They concluded that drip irrigation produced the highest yield in both seasons: ______

Method20242025
Flood4.13.8
Sprinkler4.64.4
Drip5.25.0
Average yield by irrigation method, tons per hectare (invented data).

Which choice most effectively uses data from the table to complete the statement?

  • A. sprinkler-irrigated fields outyielded flood-irrigated fields in 2024 and in 2025.
  • B. drip-irrigated fields yielded 5.2 tons per hectare in 2024 and 5.0 in 2025, more than either other method in each season.
  • C. drip-irrigated yields fell from 5.2 tons per hectare in 2024 to 5.0 in 2025.
  • D. flood-irrigated fields had the lowest yield of the study, 3.8 tons per hectare in 2025.

Best answer: B. The conclusion is that drip beat both other methods in both seasons. This option gives both drip figures and says they exceed the others each year, which the table confirms (5.2 vs 4.6 and 4.1; 5.0 vs 4.4 and 3.8).

  • A is weaker. This is accurate but compares the two other methods and never mentions drip.
  • C is weaker. This is accurate but describes a decline within drip. It does not compare drip with the other methods.
  • D is weaker. This is accurate but concerns the lowest yield, not the highest.

Question 8: Rates, not counts

Text. A teacher tracked how often 150 students used a vocabulary app and whether they passed a later reading test. She concluded that students who used the app daily were more likely to pass than students who used it weekly, since ______

App useStudentsPassed
Daily4034
Weekly6039
Never5025
App use and reading test results (invented data).

Which choice most effectively uses data from the table to complete the statement?

  • A. more weekly users (39) passed than daily users (34).
  • B. 50 of the students never used the app at all.
  • C. half of the students who never used the app passed.
  • D. 85% of daily users passed, compared with 65% of weekly users.

Best answer: D. "More likely to pass" is about rates, not counts. Daily: 34 of 40 = 85%. Weekly: 39 of 60 = 65%. The option compares the two rates the claim is about.

  • A is weaker. The counts are accurate but misleading. More weekly users passed only because there were more weekly users; their pass rate was lower.
  • B is weaker. This is accurate but describes the group the claim does not mention.
  • C is weaker. This is accurate (25 of 50) but concerns non-users, not the daily versus weekly comparison.

Question 9: Before and after

Text. In 2023, a fish ladder was added to the Coldwater Dam to help salmon swim upstream. Researchers argue the ladder worked, noting that ______

YearSalmon counted
20211,200
20221,150
20232,900
20243,100
Salmon counted above Coldwater Dam (invented data). The ladder opened in 2023.

Which choice most effectively uses data from the table to complete the statement?

  • A. an average of 1,175 salmon a year were counted above the dam in the two years before the ladder opened, compared with an average of 3,000 a year in the two years after.
  • B. 3,100 salmon were counted above the dam in 2024.
  • C. counts above the dam fell from 1,200 in 2021 to 1,150 in 2022.
  • D. counts above the dam rose every year from 2021 to 2024.

Best answer: A. To show the ladder worked, the evidence must compare counts before and after it opened. Before: (1,200 + 1,150) / 2 = 1,175. After: (2,900 + 3,100) / 2 = 3,000.

  • B is weaker. This is accurate but gives one year with nothing to compare it with.
  • C is weaker. This is accurate but describes only the years before the ladder.
  • D is weaker. This misreads the table. Counts fell between 2021 and 2022.

Question 10: Which increase was larger

Text. A bakery chain added nutrition labels to its whole-grain bread at two stores. Weekly sales rose at both, but the increase was larger at the downtown store, ______

StoreBefore labelsAfter labels
Downtown120180
Suburban150195
Weekly whole-grain loaves sold (invented data).

Which choice most effectively uses data from the table to complete the statement?

  • A. which sold 180 loaves a week after the change, compared with 195 at the suburban store.
  • B. which sold fewer loaves than the suburban store before the labels were added.
  • C. where weekly sales rose by 60 loaves, compared with 45 at the suburban store.
  • D. where sales rose by 30%, compared with 50% at the suburban store.

Best answer: C. Downtown rose 180 - 120 = 60 loaves; suburban rose 195 - 150 = 45. The option states both increases and shows downtown's was larger. (In percentage terms downtown is also larger, 50% against 30%.)

  • A is weaker. This is accurate, but it compares sales levels after the change, and the suburban figure is higher. It does not show the increase.
  • B is weaker. This is accurate but describes sales before the change, not the size of the increase.
  • D is weaker. This swaps the two percentages. Downtown rose 50% and suburban 30%.

Which traps cost the most points?

TrapExample from this setFix
True but off the claimBook club figures that do not show growth (Question 6)Name what the claim needs before reading options
Counts instead of rates39 weekly passers vs 34 daily (Question 8)Check whether the claim says "more" or "more likely"
Wrong directionSupporting evidence when the question asks what weakens (Question 2)Underline support, weaken or illustrate in the question
Misread tableA trend that does not exist (Questions 6 and 9)Check every number in the option against the table
Correlation without controlA citywide drop offered as proof of one street's change (Question 4)Look for a comparison group
Common Command of Evidence traps.

How should you practice Command of Evidence?

  • For every claim you read, say in one line what evidence would prove it. That habit transfers to every textual and quantitative item.
  • Practice reading tables and graphs on their own first: title, labels, units, then the numbers.
  • When two options look right, ask which one addresses the full claim, including every group or year it mentions.
  • Time yourself. The section gives 64 minutes for 54 questions, and data items take longer than vocabulary items, so bank time on quick questions.

Pair this set with the SAT Words in Context practice questions to cover both reading-heavy domains. The data reading you practice here also helps on Math, where the SAT data analysis practice covers tables and graphs from the problem-solving side. For a short mixed quiz, try the free SAT practice questions.

PrepSolution Editorial Team

Exam-prep editorial team

About PrepSolution

References

  1. [1] College Board (2026). Assessment Framework for the Digital SAT Suite, Version 4 (September 2026). College Board. College Board
  2. [2] College Board (2026). Reading and Writing: What's on the SAT. SAT Suite of Assessments. SAT Suite of Assessments
  3. [3] College Board (2026). SAT Structure. SAT Suite of Assessments. SAT Suite of Assessments
  4. [4] College Board (2026). Calculator Policy. SAT Suite of Assessments. SAT Suite of Assessments

Help us improve this guide

How helpful was this article?

One tap helps us understand what’s useful.

Not helpful → Very helpful

Frequently asked questions

A Reading and Writing skill in the Information and Ideas domain. You choose the fact, detail, quotation or data that supports, challenges or illustrates a specific claim.

Textual items use findings, details or quotations. Quantitative items use data from a table, bar graph or line graph to complete or support a statement.

College Board does not publish a separate count. The Information and Ideas domain, which includes Command of Evidence, makes up about 26% of scored Reading and Writing questions, or 12 to 14.

Because the question asks for evidence for a particular claim. An accurate fact that does not address that claim, or that addresses only part of it, is not the best answer.

No. College Board's calculator policy says you may not use a calculator while working on the Reading and Writing section; the Desmos calculator in Bluebook and approved handheld calculators are for Math. The numbers in data items are simple enough to compare by hand.

Keep practicing for the SAT.

Review the study tools, access options and price, or start with free practice.

Related Articles