PrepSolution

Human Resources · Study journal

Which HR Certification Should You Get First? aPHR vs PHR vs SHRM-CP

With no HR experience you can sit the aPHR or the SHRM-CP; the PHR needs 1 to 4 years. Compare eligibility, cost, format, pass rates and renewal across all three and pick your first.

By Sarah L.Published Updated Reviewed by PrepSolution Editorial Team10 min read
Inside this articleHuman Resources
Section preview 01

Which HR certification should you get first?

Two limits on this table. It cannot tell you which credential employers in your city and industry ask for, which is covered further down. And "start with" is not "stop at": you can add a second credential later, and the paths between them are covered near the end.

Read this section
On this page

If you have no HR experience, your first certification is the aPHR or the SHRM-CP, because the PHR will not accept your application yet. If you already meet the PHR experience rule, the choice is between the PHR and the SHRM-CP, and it turns on the kind of questions you want to be tested with and what the jobs you are aiming for ask for. The aPHR then only makes sense if you want a shorter, knowledge-only exam.

Each exam has its own preparation page: aPHR exam prep, PHR exam prep and SHRM-CP exam prep. If you would rather judge by the questions, the two worked questions in this article show the difference in a few minutes.

Which HR certification should you get first?

Your situationStart withWhy
Student, recent graduate or career changer with no HR experience, who wants the shortest route to a credentialaPHRNo HR experience is required, and it is the shortest of the three: 65 scored questions in 1 hour 45 minutes, all knowledge-based.
No HR title yet, but you already handle HR tasks and are comfortable with workplace scenario questionsSHRM-CPSHRM requires no HR title, degree or previous HR experience. It recommends a basic working knowledge of HR practices.
Manager outside HR who deals with hiring, discipline and employee questionsaPHRHRCI describes the aPHR as designed for people starting an HR career or managing people without formal HR training.
Working in HR, but short of the PHR experience ruleSHRM-CP or aPHRThese are the two you can apply for now. Choose by exam style, using the sample questions below.
You meet the PHR experience rule and your work is heavy on U.S. employment law and compliancePHRHRCI says the PHR validates technical and operational HR knowledge, including U.S. laws and regulations.
You meet the PHR experience rule and your work is mostly advising managers on people decisionsSHRM-CPSituational judgment items make up 40% of the exam, and half of the exam is allocated to behavioral competencies.
First-certification decision table. Eligibility is from HRCI and SHRM. The recommendations are our reading of those rules and of each exam's published format.

Two limits on this table. It cannot tell you which credential employers in your city and industry ask for, which is covered further down. And "start with" is not "stop at": you can add a second credential later, and the paths between them are covered near the end.

How do the aPHR, PHR and SHRM-CP compare at a glance?

aPHRPHRSHRM-CP
Certifying bodyHRCIHRCISHRM
HR experience requiredNone1 year with a master's degree or higher, 2 years with a bachelor's degree, or 4 years, all in a professional-level HR roleNone. No HR title or degree required
Questions65 scored plus 25 pretest90 scored plus 25 pretest134, of which 24 are unscored field-test items
Testing time1 hour 45 minutes2 hours3 hours 40 minutes, in two 110-minute sections
Question styleKnowledge-basedTechnical and operational HR, including U.S. laws and regulations80 knowledge items and 54 situational judgment items
Where you testPearson VUE test center, or at home or office with OnVUEPearson VUE test center, or at home or office with OnVUEPrometric test center, in person
When you can testThroughout the yearThroughout the yearTwo windows a year. The current one runs December 1, 2026 to February 15, 2027
Total fee$400 ($100 application plus $300 exam)$495 ($100 application plus $395 exam)$399 member or $499 nonmember standard; $350 or $450 early bird
Published pass rate71% as of December 31, 202572% as of December 31, 202569% for the May to July 2026 window
Score scale100 to 700, passing score 500100 to 700, passing score 500120 to 200, passing score 200
Valid for3 years3 years3 years
To renew45 recertification credits, or retake the exam60 HR recertification credits, or retake the exam60 professional development credits
aPHR, PHR and SHRM-CP compared. HRCI figures are from HRCI's aPHR, PHR, exam fees and pass rates pages. SHRM figures are from SHRM's Exam Options and Fees and eligibility pages.

What does the difference in question style look like?

The same HR topic can be asked two ways. HRCI's entry-level exam asks what you know. SHRM's exam also asks what you would do. Here is one topic, job analysis, asked both ways.

We wrote both questions. They are not HRCI or SHRM exam items, and the answer to the second one is our judgment of the best response, not SHRM's.

Knowledge style: what is it called?

An HR assistant is updating records for the warehouse supervisor role. Which document lists the education, experience and skills a person needs in order to do the job?

  • A. Job description
  • B. Job specification
  • C. Job evaluation
  • D. Job posting

Best answer: B. A job specification sets out the qualifications a person needs: knowledge, skills, abilities, education and experience. It is one of the two standard products of a job analysis.

  • A is not the best answer. A job description is the other product of a job analysis. It lists the duties, responsibilities and reporting lines of the job itself.
  • C is not the best answer. Job evaluation is the process of ranking jobs by their relative worth in order to set pay.
  • D is not the best answer. A job posting is the advertisement. It draws on the description and specification but is written for candidates.

Situational judgment style: what should you do?

A warehouse manager asks the HR generalist to repost a supervisor vacancy today, using the posting from three years ago. Since then the warehouse has added an automated picking system and a second shift, and the last two supervisors left within a year. Which action should the HR generalist take first?

  • A. Repost the old advertisement so the vacancy is filled quickly.
  • B. Meet with the manager and a current supervisor to review how the job has changed, and update the job description and requirements before posting.
  • C. Raise the pay range in the posting to attract stronger candidates.
  • D. Tell the manager that the posting cannot go out until a full pay study is finished.

Best answer: B. The job has changed and two people have left it quickly, so the old posting may be recruiting for a job that no longer exists. A short review with the people who know the work gives an accurate description and a posting that attracts candidates who fit, and it can be done within days.

  • A is not the best answer. It meets the deadline and repeats the conditions that produced two early exits.
  • C is not the best answer. Pay may be part of the problem, but nothing in the scenario shows it, and changing it is a decision to make with evidence.
  • D is not the best answer. It blocks the manager with a larger project than the situation calls for, and it does not address the changed duties.

If the first question felt like the kind of studying you do well, the HRCI exams will suit you. If the second felt closer to your working day, look harder at the SHRM-CP. The pairwise guides go further with worked questions at each level: aPHR vs PHR, PHR vs SHRM-CP and SHRM-CP vs aPHR.

Which of the three can you apply for today?

Eligibility removes one option for many readers, so check it before anything else.

  • aPHR. HRCI states that no HR experience is required for this knowledge-based credential.
  • PHR. You need one of three combinations: at least one year in a professional-level HR role with a master's degree or higher, at least two years with a bachelor's degree, or at least four years. HRCI defines professional-level experience on its site, and the PHR eligibility guide explains what counts.
  • SHRM-CP. SHRM states that candidates are not required to hold an HR title and do not need a degree or previous HR experience to apply. It recommends a basic working knowledge of HR practices or a degree from an academically aligned program.

So a newcomer has two choices, and an experienced practitioner has three. Nothing in either body's rules requires you to hold the aPHR before the PHR, or any HRCI credential before the SHRM-CP.

What does each one cost?

ExamFeeNotes
aPHR$400$100 application fee plus $300 exam fee. HRCI makes no refunds once an application is approved.
PHR$495$100 application fee plus $395 exam fee. Same refund rule.
SHRM-CP, SHRM member$399 standard, $350 early birdFor the current window the early-bird period ended August 31, 2026. Standard applications close December 24, 2026.
SHRM-CP, nonmember$499 standard, $450 early birdSame dates.
SHRM-CP, student$199 member or $299 nonmember standardSHRM sets separate student eligibility requirements.
Exam fees. HRCI: Exam Fees page. SHRM: Exam Options and Fees page, where standard rates include a $50 application fee and a $49 standard deadline fee.

The SHRM member price only saves money if you would join SHRM anyway, since membership has its own fee. HRCI also sells Second Chance Insurance at $250 with an application, which covers one retake of the same exam. The cost guides give the full budget for each: aPHR cost, PHR cost and SHRM-CP cost.

Which is the easiest to pass?

The published pass rates do not separate them: 71% for the aPHR, 72% for the PHR and 69% for the SHRM-CP. Read those figures with care, because they describe three different groups of test takers. Every PHR candidate has at least a year of professional-level HR experience. aPHR and SHRM-CP candidates include people with none. HRCI also reports its rates as of a date, while SHRM reports one for each testing window, and the SHRM-CP rate has ranged from 67% to 71% over the last seven windows.

In our view the better question is which exam is easiest for you. The aPHR is the shortest and asks only for knowledge. The PHR adds depth and U.S. law to that. The SHRM-CP is the longest sitting and asks you to choose the best action in workplace scenarios, where more than one option can look reasonable. The difficulty guides have the detail: aPHR pass rate and difficulty and how hard the PHR is.

How do you keep each credential?

All three run on a three-year cycle. HRCI states that the aPHR is maintained with 45 recertification credits over three years, and the PHR with 60 HR recertification credits, or by retaking the exam in either case. SHRM requires 60 professional development credits in each three-year period for the SHRM-CP. If you hold credentials from both bodies you renew each one separately under its own rules, so the cost of holding two is paid in time every cycle and not only at the exam. The HRCI recertification guide covers credits, fees and deadlines.

Which certification do employers want?

We have not found a current primary source that measures employer preference between HRCI and SHRM credentials, so this article does not claim one is preferred. We have not found job-posting data from either body that would settle it, and a salary survey cannot show which credential led to a hiring decision. For the wider question, see is an HR certification worth it.

You can get a better answer for your own market in ten minutes. Search for ten HR jobs you would apply for in your city and industry and count how many name the PHR, the SHRM-CP, either one, or neither. If your current employer pays for certification, ask which credentials its policy covers before you choose.

Can you start with one and add another later?

  • aPHR, then PHR. Both are HRCI credentials. The aPHR needs no experience, and the PHR becomes available once you meet its experience rule. Each has its own application, fee and exam.
  • aPHR, then SHRM-CP. Nothing links the two, since they come from different bodies. The aPHR gives you the vocabulary, and the SHRM-CP adds scenario judgment.
  • SHRM-CP, then SHRM-SCP. One route to SHRM's senior credential is to hold the SHRM-CP for at least three years while working in, or moving into, a strategic role. The SHRM-CP vs SHRM-SCP guide covers that step.
  • PHR and SHRM-CP together. You can hold both. Expect two fees, two exams and two renewal cycles.

How should you decide in three steps?

  1. Check eligibility. If you do not meet the PHR experience rule, your choice is the aPHR or the SHRM-CP.
  2. Try both question styles. Take the free quiz for each exam you are eligible for and note which one you would rather study for.
  3. Check your market. Count what ten real job postings ask for, and ask your employer what it reimburses.

Once you have chosen, build a plan around the exam's own outline and practice with questions that explain every option. Why PrepSolution describes how our question banks do that.

Sarah L.

PrepSolution Content Editor, HR

About PrepSolution

References

  1. [1] HR Certification Institute (2026). Associate Professional in Human Resources (aPHR). HRCI. HRCI
  2. [2] HR Certification Institute (2026). Professional in Human Resources (PHR). HRCI. HRCI
  3. [3] HR Certification Institute (2026). Exam Fees. HRCI. HRCI
  4. [4] HR Certification Institute (2026). HRCI Exam Pass Rates. HRCI. HRCI
  5. [5] HR Certification Institute (2026). Understanding Your Results Report. HRCI. HRCI
  6. [6] HR Certification Institute (2026). PHR Certification Preparation. HRCI. HRCI
  7. [7] SHRM (2026). Exam Options and Fees. SHRM. SHRM
  8. [8] SHRM (2026). Eligibility Criteria. SHRM. SHRM
  9. [9] SHRM (2026). Recertification. SHRM. SHRM

Help us improve this guide

How helpful was this article?

One tap helps us understand what’s useful.

Not helpful → Very helpful

Frequently asked questions

With no HR experience you can apply for the aPHR or the SHRM-CP. The aPHR is the shorter, knowledge-only exam with 65 scored questions. The SHRM-CP is longer and 40% of it is situational judgment. The PHR is not open to beginners because it requires 1 to 4 years of professional-level HR experience.

Yes. HRCI states that no HR experience is required for the aPHR. SHRM states that SHRM-CP candidates do not need an HR title, a degree or previous HR experience to apply.

The published pass rates are close: 71% for the aPHR and 72% for the PHR as of December 31, 2025, and 69% for the SHRM-CP in the May to July 2026 window. The groups taking each exam differ, so the rates do not rank difficulty. The aPHR is the shortest and tests knowledge only.

The SHRM-CP at the member standard rate is $399, the aPHR is $400, the PHR is $495 and the SHRM-CP for nonmembers is $499 at the standard rate. SHRM early-bird rates are $350 for members and $450 for nonmembers.

No. The PHR has its own eligibility rule based on professional-level HR experience and education. Holding the aPHR is not a requirement.

We have not found a current primary source that measures it, so we do not claim a preference. Check the job postings in your own city and industry, and ask your employer which credentials it reimburses.

Each is valid for three years. Renewal takes 45 recertification credits for the aPHR, 60 HR recertification credits for the PHR, or a retake of the exam, and 60 professional development credits for the SHRM-CP.

Keep practicing for the SHRM-CP.

Review the study tools, access options and price, or start with free practice.

Related Articles