On this page
To run the four-fifths rule, work out each group's selection rate, pick the highest rate, and compare every other group to it. If a group's rate is less than 80% of the highest rate, the federal enforcement agencies will generally treat that as evidence of adverse impact. The arithmetic takes two minutes. The judgment calls around it, such as which group is the comparison, what to do with small numbers and whether to look at the whole process or one step, are what HR certification exams test.
This article runs the calculation on three data sets: a hiring decision, a promotion with four groups, and a test with a cut score. Then it gives eight practice questions. The rule itself is summarized in the adverse impact and four-fifths rule notes. If you are preparing for the exam, SHRM-CP exam prep covers it inside the Workplace and People domains, and the same calculation appears on the PHR and SPHR.
What does the four-fifths rule actually say?
The rule comes from section 4D of the Uniform Guidelines on Employee Selection Procedures, 29 CFR part 1607, adopted in 1978 by the EEOC, the Department of Labor, the Department of Justice and the Civil Service Commission. Its first sentence is the part everyone quotes: "A selection rate for any race, sex, or ethnic group which is less than four-fifths (4/5) (or eighty percent) of the rate for the group with the highest rate will generally be regarded by the Federal enforcement agencies as evidence of adverse impact."
Two definitions in section 16 make the calculation precise. A selection rate is "the proportion of applicants or candidates who are hired, promoted, or otherwise selected." Adverse impact is "a substantially different rate of selection in hiring, promotion, or other employment decision which works to the disadvantage of members of a race, sex, or ethnic group." So the numerator is the people selected and the denominator is the people who applied or were considered, group by group.
The EEOC's Questions and Answers on the Guidelines set out the same calculation as four steps:
- Calculate the selection rate for each group: the number selected from the group divided by the number of applicants from the group.
- Find the group with the highest selection rate.
- Calculate the impact ratio for each group: its selection rate divided by the highest selection rate.
- Check whether any impact ratio is below 4/5, or 80%. If it is, adverse impact is indicated "in most circumstances."
Worked example 1: a hiring decision by sex
A distribution center fills warehouse associate roles over a quarter. 120 men and 90 women apply. The company hires 48 men and 27 women.
| Group | Applicants | Selected | Selection rate | Impact ratio | Result |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Men | 120 | 48 | 48/120 = 40% | 1.00 | Highest rate (comparison group) |
| Women | 90 | 27 | 27/90 = 30% | 30% / 40% = 0.75 | Below 80%: adverse impact indicated |
Men have the higher rate, 40%, so they are the comparison group. Women's rate of 30% divided by 40% gives 0.75. That is below 0.80, so the four-fifths rule indicates adverse impact against women in this process.
Notice what was not compared. The company hired 48 men and 27 women, but the raw head counts do not answer the question, because far fewer women applied. Comparing hires to hires, or hires to the workforce, is a different analysis. The four-fifths rule compares each group's chance of being selected once it entered the process.
Worked example 2: a promotion with four groups
A hospital system promotes staff into charge roles. Eligible employees and promotions for the year, by race and ethnic group:
| Group | Applicants | Selected | Selection rate | Impact ratio | Result |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| White | 150 | 60 | 60/150 = 40% | 40% / 45% = 0.89 | At or above 80% |
| Black | 80 | 22 | 22/80 = 27.5% | 27.5% / 45% = 0.61 | Below 80%: adverse impact indicated |
| Hispanic | 60 | 27 | 27/60 = 45% | 1.00 | Highest rate (comparison group) |
| Asian | 40 | 16 | 16/40 = 40% | 40% / 45% = 0.89 | At or above 80% |
The largest group, White employees, is not the comparison group. Hispanic employees have the highest promotion rate at 45%, so every other rate is divided by 45%. Black employees come out at 27.5% divided by 45%, which is 0.61, well below 0.80. White and Asian employees are both at 40%, which gives 0.89, above the line.
Two errors are common here. The first is comparing every group to the majority group. The Guidelines say the comparison is "the group with the highest rate." The second is comparing each group to the overall rate for everyone. That blends the comparison group into the average and understates the gap.
Section 15A(2)(a) asks users to make adverse impact determinations at least once a year for each group that makes up at least 2% of the labor force in the relevant labor area or 2% of the applicable workforce.
Worked example 3: a test inside a larger process
A manufacturer gives a written mechanical aptitude test to 200 men and 100 women. 150 men and 54 women pass. Of everyone who applied, the company finally hires 40 men and 18 women after interviews and a background check.
| Group | Applicants | Selected | Selection rate | Impact ratio | Result |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Men | 200 | 150 | 150/200 = 75% | 1.00 | Highest rate (comparison group) |
| Women | 100 | 54 | 54/100 = 54% | 54% / 75% = 0.72 | Below 80%: adverse impact indicated |
| Group | Applicants | Selected | Selection rate | Impact ratio | Result |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Men | 200 | 40 | 40/200 = 20% | 1.00 | Highest rate (comparison group) |
| Women | 100 | 18 | 18/100 = 18% | 18% / 20% = 0.90 | At or above 80% |
The test on its own shows a ratio of 0.72. The total process, from application to hire, shows 0.90. Which one counts?
The Guidelines answer this in section 4C, which they call the "bottom line." Adverse impact is checked first for the total selection process for a job. If the total process shows adverse impact, the individual components should be evaluated. If the total process does not, the federal enforcement agencies, "in usual circumstances," will not expect the employer to evaluate or validate the components and will not take enforcement action based on one of them. Section 4C then lists exceptions, including a procedure that continues the effects of past discriminatory assignments and a procedure that courts or agencies have already found not to be job related, such as certain height, weight or arrest-record requirements.
So under the Guidelines' own enforcement policy, example 3 would usually not lead the agencies to require validation of the test. That is an agency enforcement position, not a guarantee against a lawsuit, and the exam may test the difference. If the total process had shown adverse impact, the test would be the first component to examine, and section 3A says a procedure with adverse impact is treated as discriminatory unless it has been validated or another provision of the Guidelines is met.
When is a result below 80% not adverse impact?
Section 4D gives two directions of exception, and both come up on exams.
- Small numbers. Greater differences "may not constitute adverse impact where the differences are based on small numbers and are not statistically significant." The EEOC's own example: an employer selects 3 of 20 male applicants and 1 of 10 female applicants. The rates are 15% and 10%, a ratio of 0.67, yet the EEOC says the number of selections "is too small to warrant a determination of adverse impact" without more data, such as rates over a longer period.
- Atypical pools. A larger difference may also not be adverse impact where special recruiting programs made the pool of minority or female applicants atypical of the normal applicant pool.
- Smaller differences can count. A ratio above 0.80 can still be adverse impact where the difference is significant "in both statistical and practical terms," or where the employer's actions discouraged applicants from a group. The EEOC's example uses national data on arrest records: a 90% pass rate for Hispanic applicants against 96% for non-Hispanic applicants is a ratio of about 0.94, yet with a sample that large the agencies would treat the difference as adverse impact.
The EEOC also answers the question every candidate asks: does the rule tolerate a 20% difference? No. In the EEOC's words, the four-fifths rule "speaks only to the question of adverse impact, and is not intended to resolve the ultimate question of unlawful discrimination." It is a trigger for a closer look, not a safe harbor.
What the rule does not cover
The Uniform Guidelines apply to race, sex and ethnic group under Title VII and Executive Order 11246. Section 2D states that they "do not apply to responsibilities under the Age Discrimination in Employment Act" or to disability under sections 501, 503 and 504 of the Rehabilitation Act. You can still compare selection rates by age as an internal check, but the four-fifths rule in 29 CFR 1607 is not the federal standard for age or disability claims. The ADEA notes cover age separately.
Recruiting is also outside the rule. Section 2C says the Guidelines apply only to selection procedures used to make employment decisions, and that recruitment practices are not considered selection procedures.
Practice questions
These are original PrepSolution practice questions written from 29 CFR 1607 and the EEOC's Questions and Answers. They are not SHRM or HRCI exam items. Every calculation is shown in the answer.
Question 1
An employer receives 200 applications from men and 150 from women for a customer service role. It hires 60 men and 30 women. What does the four-fifths rule indicate?
- A. No adverse impact, because the employer hired more than 20% of each group
- B. Adverse impact against women, because the impact ratio is about 0.67
- C. No adverse impact, because the gap between the two rates is only 10 percentage points
- D. Adverse impact against women, because the employer hired half as many women as men
Best answer: B. Men: 60/200 = 30%. Women: 30/150 = 20%. Impact ratio: 20% / 30% = 0.67, which is below 0.80.
- A is wrong because the rule compares the two rates to each other, not each rate to a fixed floor.
- C is wrong because the rule works on the ratio of rates, not the difference in percentage points. A 10-point gap is a large ratio when the rates are low.
- D is wrong because it compares head counts. The conclusion happens to match, but the reasoning would fail with different applicant numbers.
Question 2
Promotion data for one job family: White 72 promoted of 240 eligible; Black 27 of 100; Hispanic 42 of 120; Asian 13 of 50. Which groups does the four-fifths rule flag?
- A. Black only, compared with White employees
- B. Asian only, compared with the overall promotion rate
- C. Black and Asian employees, compared with Hispanic employees
- D. None, because every group's rate is within 10 points of the others
Best answer: C. Rates: White 30%, Black 27%, Hispanic 35%, Asian 26%. Hispanic employees have the highest rate, so each rate is divided by 35%. White 0.86, Black 0.77, Asian 0.74. Black and Asian ratios are below 0.80.
- A is wrong because the comparison group is the highest-rate group, not the largest. Against White employees, the Black ratio would be 0.90 and nothing would be flagged.
- B is wrong because the overall rate (154 of 510, about 30.2%) is not the comparison the Guidelines use.
- D is wrong because the rule uses ratios, not a percentage-point band.
Question 3
An HR manager wants to use the four-fifths rule to show that a new physical ability test has no adverse impact on applicants aged 40 and over. What is the best response?
- A. Explain that the Uniform Guidelines state they do not apply to age under the ADEA, so the four-fifths rule is not the federal standard for this question
- B. Run the calculation, because the four-fifths rule applies to every protected class
- C. Use a three-fourths rule instead, which applies to age
- D. Compare the test pass rate for older applicants with the share of older workers in the local labor market
Best answer: A. Section 2D of 29 CFR 1607 says the Guidelines do not apply to responsibilities under the Age Discrimination in Employment Act.
- B is wrong because the Guidelines cover race, sex and ethnic group, not every protected class.
- C is wrong because no such rule exists in the Guidelines.
- D is wrong because it describes a different comparison, a pass rate against a labor-market share, and still does not make the Guidelines apply to age.
Question 4
A small firm hires 5 of 12 male applicants and 2 of 8 female applicants for an analyst role. The impact ratio is 0.60. According to the Uniform Guidelines and the EEOC's guidance, what should HR conclude?
- A. Adverse impact is established, and the selection procedure must be validated immediately
- B. There is no adverse impact, because the rule does not apply to employers with fewer than 100 employees
- C. The four-fifths rule cannot be calculated with fewer than 30 applicants
- D. The numbers are too small to rely on alone; look at selection rates over a longer period or in similar circumstances before drawing a conclusion
Best answer: D. Men 5/12 = 41.7%, women 2/8 = 25%, ratio 0.60. Section 4D says differences based on small numbers that are not statistically significant may not constitute adverse impact, and that evidence over a longer period may be considered.
- A is wrong because the Guidelines and the EEOC say small samples alone do not warrant a determination of adverse impact.
- B is wrong because employers with 100 or fewer employees get simplified recordkeeping under section 15A(1), not an exemption from the rule.
- C is wrong because the Guidelines set no minimum applicant count for the calculation.
Question 5
A national retailer screens 40,000 applicants with a background check. The pass rate is 90% for one ethnic group and 96% for another. The impact ratio is 0.94. Which statement is most accurate?
- A. There is no adverse impact, because the ratio is above 0.80
- B. Adverse impact exists only if the retailer intended the difference
- C. Adverse impact may still exist, because the Guidelines say smaller differences can count when they are significant in both statistical and practical terms
- D. The four-fifths rule does not apply to background checks
Best answer: C. Section 4D: "Smaller differences in selection rate may nevertheless constitute adverse impact, where they are significant in both statistical and practical terms." With 40,000 applicants, a 6-point difference is very unlikely to be chance, and one group is disqualified at 2.5 times the rate of the other (10% against 4%).
- A is wrong because 0.80 is a rule of thumb, not a safe harbor.
- B is wrong because adverse impact concerns effect, not intent.
- D is wrong because the Guidelines define selection procedures to include any measure used as a basis for an employment decision.
Question 6
A company's total hiring process for drivers shows no adverse impact, but one step, a driving record screen, has an impact ratio of 0.70 for one group. Under section 4C of the Uniform Guidelines, what will the federal enforcement agencies usually do?
- A. Usually not expect the company to evaluate or validate the individual step, unless one of the exceptions in section 4C applies
- B. Require the company to validate every step of the process
- C. Treat the step as unlawful, because any component below 0.80 is discriminatory
- D. Ignore the step permanently, because the bottom line is always a complete defense
Best answer: A. Section 4C says that when the total process shows no adverse impact, the agencies "in usual circumstances" will not expect components to be evaluated, and it lists exceptions where they will.
- B is wrong because component review is expected when the total process shows adverse impact, not as a default.
- C is wrong because a component ratio below 0.80 is evidence of adverse impact, not a finding that it is unlawful.
- D is wrong because section 4C names exceptions and describes agency enforcement policy, not an absolute defense.
Question 7
What is the selection rate for women in a hiring process where 50 women applied, 30 were interviewed and 10 were hired?
- A. 33%, because 10 of the 30 women interviewed were hired
- B. 20%, because 10 of the 50 women who applied were hired
- C. 60%, because 30 of the 50 women who applied were interviewed
- D. It depends on how many men were hired
Best answer: B. For the total selection process the selection rate is those selected (hired) divided by those who applied: 10/50 = 20%.
- A is wrong because it uses interviewees as the denominator, which measures only the final step.
- C is wrong because it is the rate for the interview step, not the hiring decision.
- D is wrong because each group's rate is calculated from that group's own numbers. Other groups matter only when the rates are compared.
Question 8
A 60-employee company asks what adverse impact records it must keep under the Uniform Guidelines. Which answer fits section 15A(1)?
- A. None, because the Guidelines apply only to federal contractors
- B. A full validity study for every selection procedure
- C. Only an annual EEO-1 report
- D. Simplified records: for each year, the number hired, promoted and terminated for each job and the number of applicants for hire and promotion, by sex and where appropriate by race and national origin, plus the selection procedures used
Best answer: D. Section 15A(1) offers simplified recordkeeping for employers with 100 or fewer employees and other users not required to file EEO-1 reports, and lists these records.
- A is wrong because the Guidelines apply to employers subject to Title VII, not only contractors.
- B is wrong because validity evidence is called for where a procedure has adverse impact, not for every procedure.
- C is wrong because the EEO-1 is a separate report, and the simplified rule exists for employers who are not required to file it.
How this shows up on SHRM and HRCI exams
Exam items on adverse impact rarely stop at the arithmetic. Expect a short table and a question about which group is the comparison, whether a small sample changes the conclusion, whether the total process or one step matters, or what HR should do next. The next step is usually to examine the selection procedure for job relatedness and consider alternatives with less adverse impact, which section 3B asks users to investigate.
At the SHRM-CP and PHR level the questions sit close to the calculation. At the SPHR level they move to policy: building annual adverse impact monitoring into the selection system and deciding when to change a procedure. The SPHR adverse impact notes cover that angle, and the PHR adverse impact notes mirror the SHRM-CP page. For the wider study plan, see the SHRM-CP study plan guide, and for full-length practice under exam conditions, the SHRM-CP exam prep course.
References
- [1] EEOC, DOL, DOJ and Civil Service Commission (1978). Uniform Guidelines on Employee Selection Procedures, 29 CFR part 1607 (2024 edition). Code of Federal Regulations, via govinfo.gov. Code of Federal Regulations, via govinfo.gov
- [2] U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (1979). Questions and Answers to Clarify and Provide a Common Interpretation of the Uniform Guidelines on Employee Selection Procedures. EEOC. EEOC
- [3] U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (2007). Employment Tests and Selection Procedures. EEOC. EEOC
Help us improve this guide
How helpful was this article?
One tap helps us understand what’s useful.
Frequently asked questions
It compares how often each group is selected. If one group's selection rate is less than 80% of the rate for the group with the highest rate, the federal enforcement agencies will generally treat that as evidence of adverse impact. It comes from section 4D of the Uniform Guidelines, 29 CFR 1607.
Divide each group's selection rate by the highest group's selection rate. A selection rate is the number selected from the group divided by the number of applicants from the group. For example, 30% divided by 40% is an impact ratio of 0.75.
No. The Uniform Guidelines compare each group with the group that has the highest selection rate, which may be a smaller group.
Not always. Section 4D says smaller differences may still be adverse impact when they are significant in both statistical and practical terms, or when the employer discouraged applicants from a group.
The Uniform Guidelines state that they do not apply to responsibilities under the Age Discrimination in Employment Act, or to disability under sections 501, 503 and 504 of the Rehabilitation Act.
Examine whether the procedure is job related and valid under the Guidelines, and investigate alternative procedures with less adverse impact, as section 3B asks. A procedure with adverse impact is treated as discriminatory under the Guidelines unless it has been validated or another provision is met.
Section 15A(2)(a) of the Guidelines asks users to make adverse impact determinations at least annually for each group that makes up at least 2% of the relevant labor force or applicable workforce.
Keep practicing for the SHRM-CP.
Review the study tools, access options and price, or start with free practice.
Related Articles
Which Employment Laws Apply at 15, 20, 50 and 100 Employees
One table of federal employment law thresholds, the counting rule each statute uses, and six practice questions. Every row is checked against the U.S. Code or the CFR.
HR Metrics Formulas: Turnover, Compa-Ratio and Cost per Hire, With 10 Practice Problems
Ten worked HR metrics problems for the SHRM and HRCI exams: turnover, voluntary turnover, compa-ratio, position in range, cost per hire, yield ratios and training ROI.
PHR Employee and Labor Relations: 10 Worked Practice Questions
Ten original PHR questions on Section 7, supervisors, campaign speech, Weingarten rights, good-faith bargaining, election bars and OSHA retaliation, each answer checked against the statute.
